I picked up a well-thumbed manual for some of the software I used for my computational chemistry research. It bristled with sticky notes of work arounds and advice.
Failing to converge? Try this. Need to queue up a job on the cluster? Here's the standard script. Check your permissions! Asterisks marked material that I used every year to train students. And on every one a plea, please don't take these books: "FRANCL LAB - DO NOT REMOVE" was printed in black Sharpie on spines and covers.
Once upon a time, if I could have chained them down or written curses in the covers like a medieval scholar, I might have. (Well, ok, I certainly could have, though I imagine my students might have been a bit put off. And the group transitioned long ago to electronic materials, so these manuals were old. Though there was the odd sticky note of advice still stuck to the wall.)
They were irreplaceable and last week I threw them out. Intentionally. Into the big blue recycling bin behind the science building. They made a big thunk as they hit the walls. I could feel that thump in my bones.
I could have found a spot on the shelves in my office for them, or at home. I could have put them on the library "free books" table, pretending that there might be someone else who would want them. Or packed them up for the local thrift store, spinning a similar tale for my conscience. I pitched them.
Clearing out my research space was hard work, emotionally (and physically — paper is heavier than you think, margins might be paper-thin, but stacks of paper are like bricks). All those irrevocable decisions about things that were once so important to me. I cannot now call back my drafts of journal articles, or jotted thoughts about weird molecular topologies that I and my students might explore. It was a lot.
I hadn't realized how much of a luxury this was.
A couple of days later, I ran across this article, "I have lost everything," at ProPublica. It's a series of handwritten notecards responding to the question, "What is something that was important to you that was taken away in a sweep?" Unhoused people lamenting was lost when their encampments were swept clear without warning. Wedding photos and a grandmother's letters. A mother's ashes. Irreplaceable things, irrevocably gone.
Until that moment I hadn't realized that my trundling cart after cart of paper to the recycling bin was an enormous privilege. I still feel the pale shadow of the aching pain of these people.
I had the privilege of choice. I have the luxury of space. Everything in that research space could have been boxed up and brought home to be stored in my garage or attic. (Though I rather think my children would not have thanked me, but still — my space, my choice.)
________
This has sat open on my desktop for a couple of days. I don't quite know how to end it. It feels trite to say don't do this to people. Perhaps all I can do is sit with this uncomfortable knowledge. Advocate when and where I can and continue working to shelter the unhoused in my neighborhood. That feels hopelessly trite, too.